GT Bmag · live demo with sample contentGet this themeAll demos

Valley edition Independent, reader-funded news for the Tamsin Valley since 2009. Get the 6 a.m. briefing →

What the falling Main Street vacancy rate does, and does not, tell us

Empty shopfronts are down to 6.1 percent across the valley. That is good news, but the number hides some differences between towns.

Dateline
Story type
Explainer
A lively urban street with storefronts, pedestrians, and vehicles during the day, evoking a bustling atmosphere.

The share of empty shopfronts on the main streets of the Tamsin Valley’s five largest towns has fallen to 6.1 percent, from 9.4 percent two years ago, according to the business desk’s autumn count. It is the lowest figure since we began counting in 2017.

That sounds like a recovery, and in some places it is. But one number for the whole valley can hide as much as it shows. Here is how to read it.

How we count

Every autumn two reporters walk the main shopping street of Wrenfield, Ashby Crossing, Millbrook, Holloway and Caddon Falls and note every ground-floor unit that is empty, being refitted, or open. A unit counts as empty if nobody is trading from it on two visits a week apart.

Where it improved

Wrenfield did best, with its rate falling from 11 percent to 5 percent, helped by the busier market hall and two new restaurants on Mill Street. Caddon Falls and Holloway also improved.

Where it did not

In Ashby Crossing the rate barely moved, at just under 10 percent. Several of its shops have become offices or flats, which takes them off the list of empty units without bringing new shoppers.

Empty shopfronts by town

Wrenfield
5.0%
Ashby Crossing
9.8%
Millbrook
6.4%
Holloway
4.9%
Caddon Falls
5.5%

What the number cannot say

An occupied shop is not always a thriving one. The count does not measure how long new businesses last, what rents they pay, or whether they are making money. Next spring we will go back to the 31 businesses that opened this year and ask them how it is going.

If you run a shop in the valley and want to tell us how your year has been, the business desk would like to hear from you.

The full count, with every street and the method we use, is published each year on the business section front. We correct it if a shop owner tells us we have recorded their unit wrongly.