A few times a week someone carries a box of records through our door, often after clearing a parent’s house. Selling a collection can feel personal, and it can be confusing when two buyers give very different numbers. This is how we approach it, and what we think you should expect from any honest buyer.
Condition matters more than age
Old does not mean valuable. Most records were pressed in large numbers, and a common album in worn condition is worth a dollar or two. The same album in near mint condition with a clean cover can be worth twenty times that.
So the first thing we do is look at every record: the vinyl, the cover and whether the inner sleeve is original. We play anything that looks like it might be special.
How an offer is built
Records sit in three groups: the ones we can sell well, the ones that will go to the dollar bins, and the ones we cannot sell at all. Our offer is roughly a third to a half of what we expect to sell the first group for, plus a small amount for the dollar records.
We explain the offer in writing, record by record for anything over $20, and you are under no obligation to accept it.
Cash or store credit
We pay the same day, in cash or by bank transfer. If you would rather take store credit, we add 30 percent, which many collectors use to trade up.
Getting the best price
Do not clean records with household products before you bring them in, and do not throw away the covers or inner sleeves, however tatty. Keep boxed sets complete. For collections over 300 records within 40 miles of Athens, we can come to you.
