Two policies can both cover your couch and still pay very different amounts after a fire. The difference usually comes down to two phrases you will find in the property part of a policy: actual cash value and replacement cost.
Actual cash value
Actual cash value generally means what something is worth today, after wear and age. A ten-year-old couch is usually worth far less than it cost new, so a policy that pays actual cash value would typically pay less for it.
The same idea can apply to roofs. Some policies pay for an older roof on an actual cash value basis, which matters a lot in a state that sees as much hail as Iowa does.
Age and condition both play a part, so two roofs of the same size can be valued quite differently after the same storm.
Replacement cost
Replacement cost generally means what it would cost to replace the item with a similar new one, without taking off for age. Some policies pay the actual cash value first and the rest once you have replaced the item and sent the receipt.
Policies that use replacement cost usually cost more, because the insurance company may pay more after a loss. Whether that trade suits you is a personal choice, and it helps to see both prices side by side.
Where to look in your policy
Check the declarations page and the property section for both phrases. A policy can use one approach for the house and another for your belongings, or a different one for the roof. Endorsements, the pages added to the policy, can change the approach too.
Ask the question before you need the answer
Nobody wants to learn which approach their policy uses while standing in a wet basement. At every annual review we point to the exact line on your policy and explain it in plain words.
This is general information, not insurance advice.
