Owners often ask how we choose a tenant. The honest answer is that we do not choose people; we check every application against the same written criteria, in the same order, and the first complete application that meets them is offered the home. That protects applicants, and it protects owners too.
The criteria come first
Before a home is listed, the owner and our leasing manager agree the criteria: income of about three times the monthly rent, verifiable rental history, no unpaid balances with a previous landlord and the pet rules for that home. The criteria are posted with the listing and handed to anyone who asks before they pay an application fee.
We never change the criteria for one applicant. If an owner wants to relax them, for example to accept a co-signer, the change applies to everyone from that day on.
The order of checks
Every adult who will live in the home applies separately. We verify identity, then income with pay stubs, an offer letter or bank statements, then call previous landlords. Credit and background reports come last, run through a screening service with the applicant’s written consent.
Landlord calls tell us more than any report. We ask the same four questions every time: did they pay on time, did they give notice, how did the home look at move-out, and would you rent to them again.
A clear answer
Applicants hear from us within two working days of a complete application. If we decline, we say so in writing and name the screening service we used, so the applicant can see and correct the report.
Fair housing law applies to every step, and a written checklist is the simplest way to make sure we follow it. It also means an owner can see exactly why a tenant was approved.
What owners see
Owners receive a one-page summary of the approved application: income ratio, rental history notes and the lease start date. Copies of identity documents and full reports stay in our secure files.
