GT Plumb · live demo with sample contentGet this themeAll demos

24/7 emergency line · Office Mon–Fri 7:00–18:00, Sat 8:00–14:00 · 1450 W Southern Ave, Mesa, AZ 85202 Call +1 (480) 555-0163

Tank or tankless: choosing a water heater for a Valley home

Upfront cost, running cost, space and hard water: the questions we ask before recommending one or the other.

·

Indoor view of a water heater neatly installed in a cabinet with modern decor.

When a water heater fails, most people replace it with the same kind they had. That is often the right call, but it is worth asking a few questions first, because the next heater will be with you for ten years or more.

How a tank compares

A standard tank keeps 40 or 50 gallons hot all the time. It costs less to buy and install, it is simple to repair, and it delivers a lot of hot water at once, which helps when two showers and the dishwasher run together.

The downside is standby loss: the tank reheats water you are not using. In a hot Arizona garage that loss is smaller than in colder places, but it is still there. A 50-gallon gas tank, installed, usually costs between $1,650 and $2,400.

How tankless compares

A tankless heater fires only when you open a hot tap, so it never runs out and does not waste energy keeping water warm. It is compact and mounts on a wall, which frees up space in a small garage or closet.

It costs more to install, typically $3,200 to $4,800, because many homes need a larger gas line or a new vent. It also needs a yearly descale in hard water, and there is a short wait for hot water at the tap.

The questions we ask

How many people live in the house, and how many showers run at the same time? Is there room for a tank, and is the gas line big enough for a tankless unit? Do you plan to stay in the house long enough for the energy savings to add up?

We give you a written price for both options when it makes sense, and we never push a tankless unit when a tank would serve you better.