More than half the replacements we quote in the metro now include an impact-resistant option. The question homeowners ask is simple: is the extra cost worth it here?
What impact-resistant means
Impact-rated shingles are tested by dropping steel balls of increasing size onto them. The highest class survives a two-inch ball without cracking. The shingles are made with a rubber-modified asphalt that flexes when it is hit instead of fracturing.
They still dent and scuff in very large hail, and no shingle is hail-proof. They do take far more hits before water can get through.
What they cost
On a typical 25-square roof, impact-resistant shingles add roughly 15 to 25 percent to the price of a standard architectural shingle roof. On our estimate range table that is the difference between the first and second price column.
Insurance and resale
Many Oklahoma insurers offer a premium discount for impact-rated roofs, and some offer a lot. Ask your agent for the exact number before you choose, and keep the product label and our invoice, because the insurer will ask for proof.
Buyers also notice. A recent impact-rated roof is a line on a listing that answers a question every Oklahoma buyer has.
When standard shingles still make sense
If you plan to sell in the next two years, or the roof is mostly shaded by large trees that break up hail, a standard architectural shingle may be the sensible choice. We price both on every estimate so you can compare them side by side.
Whichever you choose, the rest of the roof matters as much as the shingle: new drip edge, sealed valleys and proper nailing are what keep an impact-rated roof performing the way the label promises.
