About Salinger
A reading room on the web, run by a former librarian
Salinger is where Maren Holloway reviews new fiction, picks one book of the month and keeps a yearly reading challenge for 21,000 borrowers.
640+
books reviewed
9
years behind a library desk
21k
Borrower’s Letter readers
0
paid reviews, ever
From the Wrenfield branch desk to a blog
Maren spent nine years at the front desk of a small branch library, stamping date-due slips and telling people what to read next. In 2017 she started writing her recommendations down, at first on index cards by the returns trolley and then here.
Every book reviewed on Salinger is read cover to cover. If Maren gives up on a book, she says so in a check-in rather than writing a review of half of it.
Review copies are labelled at the top of every review, inside the borrower’s card. Reviews are never paid, never sold and never shown to a publisher before they are published.
What you can expect from every review
- A borrower’s card with author, pages, format and how I got the book
- Ratings out of five, where three is a good book
- No spoilers past the first act without a warning
- Who the book is for, and who it is not for
- An honest note on what did not work
The people in the reading room
Reviewer and editor
Maren Holloway
Reads about a hundred books a year and reviews the ones worth talking about. Former branch librarian.
Q&A editor
Desmond Pryce
Arranges and edits the author Q&As. Reads mostly mysteries, always on paper.
Challenge keeper
Hana Ivers
Runs the reading challenge, the Wall of Borrowers and the reading-room chats.
A good review tells you who a book is for. That is all a librarian ever does.
Maren Holloway, founder
Start with the latest reviews
Get your library card
The Borrower’s Letter: one review, the book of the month and three books worth borrowing, every Sunday.


