GT Salinger · live demo with sample contentGet this themeAll demos

Due back soon: November’s book of the month is The Glasswright of Lowmere. The reading-room chat opens on the 28th.

How I rate books, and why three stars is a compliment

What each star means on this blog, why I do not give half the internet five stars and how I decide between a three and a four.

Open books and glasses on a marble table, with notepad for study or research context.

A reader wrote last month to ask why I gave Static Over Calder Bay three stars when I clearly enjoyed it. It is a fair question, and the answer is that stars here do not work the way they do in most online shops. So here is how I rate books, written down once so I can link to it.

What the stars mean

  • Five stars: a book I will reread and press on everyone I know. I give two or three a year.
  • Four stars: an excellent book with a flaw I can name. Most of my favourites live here.
  • Three stars: a good book. I am glad I read it and I would recommend it to the right reader.
  • Two stars: a book with real problems that I finished anyway, usually for one good thing in it.
  • One star: I almost never give it. If a book is that bad for me, I usually do not review it at all.

Why three is a compliment

Most online ratings cluster between four and five, which means they tell you very little. If every book is wonderful, nothing is. I want my scale to be useful, so three stars means what it says: good. A three-star book is worth your time if its strengths are the things you love.

A rating is a signpost, not a verdict. The review is where the reasons live.

Half stars

I use half stars when a book sits right on a line. Under the Marram Grass got three and a half: the birds were a four, the people a three. The Glasswright of Lowmere got four and a half because its ending wobbles, and I would rather tell you that than round up.

What never changes a rating

How I got the book. Review copies are labelled at the top of every review, inside the borrower’s card, and they get exactly the same scale as books I bought or borrowed. Publishers do not see reviews before they go up, and nobody can pay for a review on this blog. That is the whole point of having stars at all.

If you ever think a rating does not match the review, write to me. Sometimes I am wrong, and I would rather hear it.