GT Slice · live demo with sample contentGet this themeAll demos

Mon–Thu 11:00–22:00 · Fri–Sat 11:00–23:30 · Sun 12:00–21:00 · 2147 W Belmont Ave, Chicago, IL 60618 Call +1 (773) 555-0148

What makes a tavern-style pizza (and why we cut it in squares)

Chicago’s everyday pizza is thin, crisp and shared in squares. Here is how it is made and why the corners go first.

·

Mouth-watering pizza topped with eggs and meat, perfect for dinner.

Visitors come to Chicago for deep dish, but ask people who grew up here what they order on a weeknight and most will say thin crust, cut in squares. It is the pizza of neighbourhood taverns, bowling alleys and Friday nights in front of the television, and it is the only kind we bake.

A dough that cracks, not folds

Tavern dough is lean and low in water. We mix it every morning with flour, water, salt, a pinch of yeast and a little oil, then let it rest in the cooler overnight. The long rest gives flavour without making the crust bready.

Before it is topped, the dough is rolled very thin, almost to the edge of the pan. There is no puffy rim: the toppings go nearly all the way out, which is why the edges come out of the oven crisp and slightly charred.

Sauce, cheese and sausage, in that order

The sauce goes on uncooked, so it tastes of tomatoes rather than of a long simmer. Whole-milk mozzarella covers it edge to edge.

Sausage is the classic topping. Ours is seasoned with fennel and pinched on raw in small pieces, so it cooks in the oven and its fat seasons the cheese around it.

Why squares?

A thin pie cut in wedges droops at the tip. Cut in squares, every piece stays firm enough to pick up with one hand. The squares also make sharing easy: little ones take a centre piece, and the crisp corner pieces are claimed by whoever is fastest.

If you prefer wedges, ask when you order. We will cut it any way you like, but we think you will come back to squares.

How to order it like a regular

Ask for it well done or extra-crispy if you like a darker bottom. It costs nothing and adds about two minutes in the oven. Sausage and giardiniera is the order we hear most, followed by a plain cheese for the kids.