GT Watches · live demo with sample contentGet this themeAll demos

Tue–Fri 10:00–18:00 · Sat 10:00–16:00 · 1612 Bardstown Rd, Louisville, KY 40205 Call +1 (502) 555-0147 Request a repair →

Getting jewelry appraised for insurance: what to expect

What an insurance appraisal includes, how long it takes, and why the value is often higher than what you paid.

·

From above closeup of crop anonymous female jeweler with magnifying glass and diamonds in workshop

Most home insurance policies cover only a small amount for jewelry unless each valuable piece is listed. To list a ring, a necklace or a watch, your insurer usually asks for a written appraisal from a jeweler.

What we look at

For a diamond ring we measure the stone, estimate its weight in the setting, grade colour and clarity under magnification and test the metal. For a watch we note the movement type, case material, size, condition and any service history.

Every appraisal includes clear photos and a description detailed enough for the insurer to replace the piece with one of like kind and quality if it is lost.

Why the figure can surprise you

An insurance appraisal states the retail replacement value: what it would cost to buy a similar piece new from a jeweler today. That is often higher than what you paid years ago, and always higher than what you could sell it for.

If you want to sell a piece, ask for a different kind of valuation. We explain the difference at the counter so the right figure goes on the right paper.

How it works at our shop

Bring the piece in during opening hours or book a drop-off with a repair request. Most items stay with us for 48 hours; simple pieces can sometimes be done while you wait. You receive a signed written appraisal and a digital copy by email.

The first item is $75 and each extra item at the same visit is $40.

Update it every few years

Gold and stone prices move, so insurers often ask for a new appraisal every three to five years. Keep the old one with the new one: together they make a record of the piece and its condition over time. Keep photos of every piece in a safe place too, away from the jewelry itself.