I write in my books, and I know some readers find this upsetting. I have friends who will not crack a spine. I have a cousin who reads with the book held open at an angle so the pages do not bend. I admire them, and I am not one of them.
My books are full of pencil. Underlines, small ticks, question marks, the occasional exclamation and, in the books I love most, whole sentences written sideways up the margin.
Why pencil
Pencil because it is quiet. A pen in a margin is a declaration; pencil is a conversation. I can rub it out, though I never do. And pencil ages well. My notes from twenty years ago have faded to a soft grey, which feels right, like a voice heard from the next room.
What the margins say
When I reread a book I am now reading two texts: the author’s and my own. The younger me underlined every sentence about loneliness and freedom. The me of ten years later underlined sentences about work. Now I find myself marking the passages about rooms, light and food. I could write my autobiography from these margins, and it would be more honest than one written on purpose.
The margin is where a book becomes yours.
Some of my old notes embarrass me. “Yes!!” next to a sentence I now find silly. A long argument with a character who was clearly right. I leave them all. A clean book tells you nothing about who read it. A marked one tells you how a mind moved through it, one page at a time.
If you have never written in a book, try it with one you own and do not plan to sell. One light tick next to the first sentence that stops you. It is a small, private act of attention, and it is surprisingly hard to stop.
