GT Nucleus · live demo with sample contentGet this themeAll demos

A margin full of pencil

I write in my books. Lightly, in pencil, and constantly. Here is why, and what twenty years of marginalia say about the person holding the pencil.

Essay length
Short essay
Written in
Burlington, Vermont
Series
The reading year
Close-up of an open book with a highlighter and sticky notes for study reference.

I write in my books, and I know some readers find this upsetting. I have friends who will not crack a spine. I have a cousin who reads with the book held open at an angle so the pages do not bend. I admire them, and I am not one of them.

My books are full of pencil. Underlines, small ticks, question marks, the occasional exclamation and, in the books I love most, whole sentences written sideways up the margin.

Why pencil

Pencil because it is quiet. A pen in a margin is a declaration; pencil is a conversation. I can rub it out, though I never do. And pencil ages well. My notes from twenty years ago have faded to a soft grey, which feels right, like a voice heard from the next room.

What the margins say

When I reread a book I am now reading two texts: the author’s and my own. The younger me underlined every sentence about loneliness and freedom. The me of ten years later underlined sentences about work. Now I find myself marking the passages about rooms, light and food. I could write my autobiography from these margins, and it would be more honest than one written on purpose.

The margin is where a book becomes yours.

Some of my old notes embarrass me. “Yes!!” next to a sentence I now find silly. A long argument with a character who was clearly right. I leave them all. A clean book tells you nothing about who read it. A marked one tells you how a mind moved through it, one page at a time.

If you have never written in a book, try it with one you own and do not plan to sell. One light tick next to the first sentence that stops you. It is a small, private act of attention, and it is surprisingly hard to stop.