In January I made a list of the six novels I loved most between the ages of nineteen and twenty-five. Not the best books I had read then. The ones I pressed on friends, quoted in letters and carried from flat to flat. I decided to reread one every two months and write down what happened.
It is November, and I have finished five and abandoned one. The results are not what I expected.
The two that held
Two of the books are as good as I remembered, and better. A thin novel about a family of fishermen on a northern coast, which I loved at twenty for its storms, I now love for its kitchen scenes. The storms are still there, but I had not noticed how much of the book is about who makes the tea and who is too tired to.
The three that changed
Three books had changed, by which I mean I had. A long novel about a young man in a big city, which once felt like a portrait of me, now feels like a portrait of someone I would cross the street to avoid. It is still a fine book. I just no longer believe him.
A book you loved at twenty is a letter from the person you were. You do not have to agree with it to keep it.
The one I could not finish
The sixth I put down at page ninety. It was a clever, cold book about clever, cold people, and at twenty I thought cleverness and coldness were the same as depth. I do not think the book is bad. I think it was the right book for a year of my life that is over, and I am glad I do not need it any more.
I recommend the exercise to anyone. Pick the books that made you, not the ones you think should have. Read them slowly. Keep a pencil nearby. You will learn a great deal about the books, and more about the reader.
The six books
- The Salt Ledger, by Ruth Ammons (held up)
- Northern Kitchens, by Tove Lindqvist (held up)
- City of Small Hours, by Daniel Okafor (changed)
- The Glass Orchard, by Mira Sand (changed)
- Letters to a Younger Brother, by Paul Ferrante (changed)
- A Cold Season, by Hal Westbrook (not finished)
All six are on the shelf by my desk. Five of them have new pencil in the margins.
