Every week someone at the stand asks the same thing as we hand over a warm box: does this go in the fridge? The answer depends on what is inside the crust. Fruit pies and custard pies behave very differently once they leave our kitchen.
Fruit pies: the counter is fine
Apple, peach, blackberry and cherry pies are full of sugar and fruit acid, which makes them stable at room temperature. Leave the pie in its box, or cover it loosely with a clean tea towel, and it keeps well on the counter for up to two days.
Do not wrap a fruit pie in plastic while it is still warm. The steam softens the top crust and the crumb topping turns soggy. Let it cool fully first, which takes about three hours for a pie straight from our oven.
Pumpkin, chess, sweet potato and pecan: into the fridge
Pies made with eggs and milk or cream are custard pies, and they belong in the fridge within two hours of pickup. Pumpkin, sweet potato, chess and pecan pies all fall into this group.
Covered, they keep for three to four days. Take them out about thirty minutes before serving: a custard tastes better slightly cool than fridge cold, and the crust loses its chill.
Warming a pie up again
A fruit pie on day two is lovely warmed. Put it in a 175 °C (350 °F) oven for twelve to fifteen minutes, loosely covered with foil so the edges do not darken. The crust crisps again and the filling loosens.
Custard pies are best served cool or at room temperature. Warming them can make the filling weep and crack.
Freezing for later
Fruit pies freeze well for up to two months. Cool, wrap tightly in two layers and thaw overnight at room temperature before warming in the oven. Custard pies do not freeze as well, so we suggest ordering them for the day you need them.
If you are collecting a holiday preorder a day early, tell us in the notes. We will suggest which pies travel and keep best for your plans.
