Holiday pie preorders
Holiday pies, baked the morning you collect them
Thanksgiving, Christmas and Easter are our busiest weeks. Preorder your pies, choose a pickup day and skip the line at the barn.
Order deadlines
- Any week: 2 days ahead
- Thanksgiving: the Friday before
- Christmas: the Friday before
- Easter: the Wednesday before
Holiday deadlines and pickup days
Deadlines close at 18:00, or earlier when the ovens are full. Every holiday pie is baked on your pickup morning.
| Holiday | Order by | Pickup days | Pickup times |
|---|---|---|---|
| Thanksgiving | The Friday before | Tuesday or Wednesday before | 9:00–18:00 |
| Christmas | The Friday before | December 22 or 23 | 9:00–17:00 |
| Easter | The Wednesday before | Saturday before Easter | 9:00–15:00 |
| Mother’s Day | The Wednesday before | Saturday before | 9:00–18:00 |
| Fourth of July | Three days before | July 2 or 3 | 9:00–18:00 |
Holiday pies and prices
All pies are 9-inch with an all-butter crust. V vegetarian, N contains nuts.
| Pie | Tags | Holidays | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| Apple crumb | V | All year | $24 |
| Pumpkin | V | Thanksgiving, Christmas | $22 |
| Kentucky chess | V | All year | $20 |
| Brown sugar pecan | V · N | Thanksgiving, Christmas | $28 |
| Sweet potato | V | Thanksgiving, Christmas | $22 |
| Holiday pie box: any 3 pies | V | Thanksgiving, Christmas | $66 |
| Cider donuts | V | Thanksgiving, Christmas | $16 a dozen |
Which pies for which table
6–8 guests
One pie
Apple crumb or pumpkin. A slice each, with a little left for Friday.
10–16 guests
Two pies
One fruit and one custard pie: apple crumb with pumpkin or chess.
18–24 guests
The holiday pie box
Three pies of your choice, plus a dozen cider donuts for the morning.
How holiday preorders work
- Order early. Through the preorder form, by phone or at the stand, before the deadline.
- We confirm by text. Within one working day, with your total and pickup day.
- We bake on your day. Holiday pies come out of the oven on the morning of your pickup.
- Collect in the pickup tent. Next to the barn, with your name on the box. Pay when you collect.
Preorder questions
Can I change my order?
Yes, until 48 hours before your pickup day. Call or reply to your confirmation text.
What if I cannot collect on time?
Call us. We hold pies until closing, and fruit pies until the next morning if needed.
Do you deliver?
Not for holiday orders. Office orders of ten or more pies can be delivered within 15 miles of the farm for $20.
Do I pay in advance?
No. Holiday preorders are paid when you collect, by card or cash.
Can you leave nuts out?
We can leave pecans off the pies you choose, but tell us about allergies when you order. Our kitchen handles nuts, gluten, dairy and eggs, so we cannot promise any dish is free of them.
Put your pies on the list
Order early in November for Thanksgiving: in busy years the ovens fill a week before the deadline. Questions? Call +1 (859) 555-0147.